When Did The “Free Market Is Always Right” Idea Become The Truth?
Tuesday, March 16th, 2010If you think about it, free markets are obviously not always right. Our current recession is just the most recent example of free markets getting it seriously wrong. In point of fact, during the past 30 years free markets have suffered serious collapses seven times in the US alone.
It wasn’t always so, by the way. After the regulations imposed during the Great Depression (another problem caused by free markets not getting it right) America enjoyed more than 40 years of avoiding financial collapses.
But starting with the Reagan Presidency, Adam Smith’s “invisible hand” insight morphed into what I call “Capitalism On Steroids.” The lessons of the Great Depression were forgotten (as well as what Smith had in mind when he coined the “invisible hand” concept) and out of that memory hole came the idea that free markets would always come up with the best possible solution to a problem. The flip side to this goofy idea was another, equally goofy one, that government’s can’t really do anything good.
Goofy or not, a lot of people believe it to be so. That history clearly shows it isn’t true seems to be an irrelevant observation for these folks.
It’s as though someone pointed to the West one morning and remarked “let’s enjoy the sunrise” as the sun obviously rose in the East. And a lot of people did look to the West, as recommended, murmuring “ahh what a beautiful sunrise” into their own shadows.
But enough of that. What is true is that free markets have strengths and weaknesses as do governments. When things work well it’s often because they are working in tandem. On the same page, if you like.
From my perspective, governments are best that wisely govern or regulate markets. Governments set the ground rules within which markets can perform not only efficiently, but in a way that does not undermine the safety and health of the nation.
Many if not most of the obvious problems now pestering our country could not have occurred without the “free markets” always get things right faith.
Our financial system is on the rocks because of weakened regulations and regulators who were looking West for the sunrise.
Our agricultural system has turned against its own citizens, producing shadow food that is often toxic. Again with the help of regulators who believe, if only we let these companies alone, they will provide the best answers to our food problems. Same philosphy at work here, and you can count on this, the same lousy result will evolve.
And the flip side of this goofy idea is at work as well. Obviously, if you believe the government can’t do anything good, then you certainly don’t want to pay taxes. So you come up with the nostrum that tax cuts are always the right thing to do, because the free markets will have more money to figure out their solutions to our problems.
History shows that the only thing across the board tax cuts are sure to create is deficits. In the US, periods of strong income and job growth have been just as frequent when tax rates were strongly progressive as when they weren’t.
I’d say “look it up if you don’t believe me,” but I’m talking to a group of folks who have suspended their belief in history. Which means inevitably, we’re all going to repeat our mistakes.
If there’s one thing I can count on it’s that this new “philosophy” about the invincibility of free markets will give us another whiz bang of a financial meltdown as well as create a multitude of other problems in every aspect of our economy.
